Town Departments banner graphic


Community Development /  Requests for Proposals

Upcoming – October 2026

Former Eggertsville Community Center – Municipal Property For Sale

The Town of Amherst will be offering the former Eggertsville Community Center for sale through a competitive Request for Proposal (RFP) process. It is anticipated that the RFP will be released in November 2026.

Located at 4110 Baily Avenue, Amherst NY 14226, the Eggertsville Community Center is a rare and distinctive adaptive reuse opportunity within a striking former Mid-Century Modern church (12,800 sq.ft.). The property boasts an expansive sanctuary with flexible interior space, generous community/dining room with adjoining kitchen, private courtyard, office space, and plentiful on-site parking, all situated on a 1.2 acre lot.

Click the following link to access the most recent building plan/site plan set for property:

2008 Building Permit/Site Plan Set for 4110 Bailey Avenue, Amherst NY 14226

Some of the repairs/improvements conducted by the Town over the years include:

  • 2015 new Roof (full tear-off)
  • 2008 New Air Conditioning Condenser
  • ADA Bathrooms
  • Kitchen upgrades

Contacts:

To request a tour of the facility, please contact Sean Pellow, Amherst Facilities Department at (716) 631-7061 or spellow@amherst.ny.us.

For information or questions regarding the upcoming RFP, including a request to be placed on the direct solicitation list, contact Laurie Stillwell, Community Development Director (716) 631-7050 or lstillwell@amherst.ny.us.

The Town will accept competitive offers based upon the terms of the RFP. Check back to this webpage and/or request to be placed on the direct solicitation list to access the RFP, once it has been released. The Release of the RFP will also be noticed in the Amherst Bee and Buffalo News.

About Amherst

The Town of Amherst was established in 1818 and celebrated its 200th Anniversary in 2018. The town has a geographical area of 53.6 square miles and a population of greater than 122,000.

Disclaimer, Copyright and Maintenance
How to use our site

Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)

The Town of Amherst ADA Coordinators are Robert McCarthy (Director of Human Resources) and Mark Berke (Commissioner of Buildings).

Click for more information about ADA.

Website Contact

The Town of Amherst takes great pride in providing useful, timely and accurate information through its official website. We encourage public participation in our website and ask that you provide your feedback to help us make our site even better. Contact the website administrator at toawebsite@amherst.ny.us.

Get in Touch

  • General Information:
    (716) 631-7000
  • Email:
    toainfo@amherst.ny.us
  • Address:
    Municipal Building (Town Hall)
  • 5583 Main Street
  • Williamsville, NY 14221


Try our Accessibility Menu, located in the top corner, to customize your browsing experience, including options for text size, contrast, and navigation assistance.